Switzerland adopts EU Sanctions against Russia - What does this mean?

SECTIONS
  1. Introduction
SHARE

The Swiss Federal Council took a position on the armed conflict currently taking place in Ukraine and adopts the entire sanctions package against the Russian Federation by the EU. This is a complete novelty in the foreign policy of Switzerland as a neutral state and confirms its commitment to upholding international law and caring for security and peace in the international arena. It is also a clear gesture towards a political rapprochement with its most important trading partner, which is the EU.

System of legal bases for imposing sanctions in CH

The sanctions complex currently in force in Switzerland is regulated by the federal law on the implementation of international sanctions (EmbA). Article 1 of the above-mentioned Federal Law authorizes the Swiss Federal Council to implement the instruments in compliance with international law and with international human rights standards.

From a practical point of view, the Swiss Federal Council has the power to implement the sanctions imposed on Russia and a number of entities related to Kremlin policy by the United Nations (UN). The Swiss Federal Council is also authorized to impose sanctions adopted by the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), as well as sanctions against the Kremlin by the European Union (EU).

The State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO) was instructed by executive regulations to monitor and impose sanctions by ordinance.

In order to ensure the highest degree of effectiveness of the imposed restrictions, Switzerland has decided to choose the model of so-called smart sanctions. This model is based on the fact that the sanctions in question target specific persons, entities and organizations, and in a directional manner prevent them from circumventing them. The names of sanctioned individuals, entities, as well as organizations, are listed in the annexes to individual regulations published by SECO on an ongoing basis.

"Back then" - Sanctions in Crimea, 2014

After the annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation in 2014, the European Union created a system of sanctions (Council Regulation (EU) No. 833/2014), which Switzerland did not accept. The solution that Switzerland then adopted was that it undertook to take all necessary measures to prevent Switzerland from being used to circumvent sanctions imposed by the EU. To this end, SECO published a regulation of 2 April 2014 on measures to avoid the circumvention of international sanctions in connection with the situation in the territory of Ukraine (SR 946.231.176.72).

The sanctioning instruments introduced by Switzerland were aimed at ensuring that the prohibition of commercial relations with entities that were subject to sanctions would be effective and could not be circumvented. Switzerland, however, has not decided to freeze funds.

"This time around" - The situation in Ukraine, 2022

The European Union, in response to the military intervention of the Russian Federation in Ukraine, adopted a package of new sanctions (Council Regulation (EU) 2022/328) against the Russian Federation. This package orders the absolute freezing of assets and the closure of the EU capital market for some entities and individuals, mainly oligarchs and some Russian politicians. The indicated package of sanctions also covers the ban on the export of dual-use items to the Russian Federation, and introduces, inter alia, visa restrictions.

The Swiss Federal Council decided to accept in full the sanctions imposed by the EU on the Russian Federation and instructed SECO to rename the existing regulation as follows: Order of March 4 on measures in connection with the situation in Ukraine (946.231.176.72), hereinafter "Ukraine ordinance".

Two different responses from Switzerland

The distinction between the adoption of "measures to prevent the circumvention of EU sanctions" and the adoption of sanctions in full has a symbolic, legal as well as practical significance.

From a formal and legal point of view, Switzerland this time did not stop at the prohibition of circumventing sanctions imposed by the EU and decided to freeze assets, thereby departing from the long-cultivated principle of neutrality.

Current measures adopted by Switzerland

In accordance with the modified Ukrainian regulation, Switzerland currently maintains, among others, the following restrictions on financial services, goods, and freedom of movement.

Financial sanctions

Financial sanctions - in the narrow sense, i.e. freezing of assets and prohibitions on making economic resources available (§3 of the Ukrainian Ordinance) were introduced as follows:

  • Assets belonging to persons, entities or organizations mentioned in the respective lists are frozen and it is prohibited to make economic resources available to such persons, entities, or organizations. This means that no business relations can be entered into or no business transactions can be fulfilled involving listed persons, entities, or organizations.
  • Financial institutions have reporting obligations concerning frozen assets.
  • Financial institutions face prohibitions related to the issuance and trading of transferable securities and money market instruments.
  • Financial institutions are prohibited from granting certain loans.
  • Banks are prohibited from receiving (new) deposits over CHF 100,000 from Russian citizens or natural and legal persons in Russia prevails.
  • Banks face reporting obligation for pre-existing deposits of more than CHF 100,000.
  • Prohibitions related to transactions with the Central Bank of Russia prevail.
  • Prohibitions as to the provision of specialized communication services for payment transactions prevail.

Goods Restrictions

Goods restrictions and sectorial sanctions (Section 2 of the Ukraine ordinance) have been introduced as follows:

  • A prohibition on the sale, supply, export, transit and transport of arms and ammunition, dual-use goods (annex 2 GCO), special military goods (annex 3 GCO), and goods according to a newly established list destined for the development of the defense and security sectors to or for use in the Russian Federation or (under certain circumstances) to/in the Ukraine. Note that the latter list contains goods that were thus far, and prior to the issuance of the new ordinance, not considered ‘controlled’. Note further that certain exceptions/exemptions may apply. Note also that the provision of services is also prohibited.
  • A ban on the import of firearms, ammunition, explosives, pyrotechnic articles and gunpowder from the Russian Federation or Ukraine.
  • A prohibition on the sale, supply, export and transit of aerospace/aviation goods (currently aircrafts and components), and oil refining and oil industry goods as per a specified list to or for use in the Russian Federation.
  • A prohibition on the imports of goods originating in designated territories (Crimea, Sevastopol, Donetsk, Luhansk) without a certificate of origin issued by a Ukrainian authority.
  • An export ban on certain goods and services into designated territories and for use by designated individual/organizations/entities.

Freedom of Movement

  • Entry bans against a number of individuals close to the Kremlin prevail.
  • A suspension of the 2009 agreement on visa facilitation for Russian nationals has been introduced.
  • A closure of Swiss airspace affecting aircrafts operated by Russian carriers has been implemented (excluding flights for humanitarian, medical or diplomatic purposes).

How should businesses respond to the measures?

Businesses should scrutinize their upstream and downstream supply chains, the universe of business partners and buyers, including the banks they use to carry out transactions, and make an assessment as to whether any of these expose them to sanctions risks.

The first and most straightforward way of finding out what your 3rd party risk exposure looks like is to perform KYC checks.

Businesses should also analyze the items they manufacture, distribute or import. They should be aware of the correct classification of said goods, origin information, and licensing requirements potentially applicable to said goods.

Navigating the complex matter of international law is time-consuming and requires specialist legal knowledge. Eberhard Advisory provides you with expert knowledge in the presented issues and ensures that your business is always safe.